Tuesday, March 17, 2020

Case Density VS Case Counts

Yesterday, the US had 4,744 Cases of Covid-19 and France had 6,633 cases.  These numbers are pretty close, but the US has a population of 331 million, while France has less than 67 million.  Obviously, every case is concerning; but when you try to compare how different countries are faring, doesn't it make sense to factor in population?  If we have almost five times the population of France, are our similar case counts really equivalent?

I'd love for others to weigh in on the question.  In my opinion, the danger of the growth of the virus is how it grows exponentially.  It grows that way because of the increased opportunity for new cases as more contagious people are in contact with the rest of the country.  That seems a function of density (ie how many contagious people are mixed in with those uninfected.  Because of the population differences, the current status on my sheet shows that France has 99 cases per 1 million people and the US has only 14.3 cases per 1 million.

Current Status
CountryPopulationCasesCases/1M
Vietnam97,339,000610.6
Indonesia264,000,0001720.7
South Africa56,720,000621.1
Argentina44,270,000681.5
Philippines104,900,0001871.8
New Zealand4,705,882122.6
Thailand69,040,0001772.6
Australia25,510,2041776.9
Chile18,050,0001568.6
Canada37,742,0003759.9
USA331,000,0004,74414.3
Malaysia32,366,00067320.8
UK66,440,0001,54323.2
Singapore5,612,00024343.3
China1,439,323,00080,88156.2
Germany83,697,0007,97495.3
France66,990,0006,63399.0
South Korea51,269,0008,320162.3
Spain46,756,00011,279241.2
Italy60,462,00027,980462.8

This chart seems to show that the US is doing comparatively much better than other countries, given its population.  Remember that the US was slower to get to pace on testing so it could be that our case count just seems lower, but it's still a good look for us.  We might see even more if we put countries on a common timeline -- how does our 14.3 count compare to other countries on their day 15?  THere are fewer countries at day 15, but here's the chart:

CountryDay 15
USA14.33
China14.20
Italy121.98
South Korea122.57
Spain241.23
Germany69.45
France67.16
Singapore43.30
Here, the US is much lower than everyone else who started day 1 on or before we did, with the exception of China.  Remember, China has by far the most cases but also a much higher population of 1.4 Billion.   If we graph the growth of the virus on a common timeline relative to the whole country's population, we get a very different look than my last post.  




Here you can see that China and the US are practically flat, while Spain and Italy are still rocketing upwards.  Singapore is higher than the US now because of its small population.  

For those in the US, I hope this is encouraging; but it is still VERY important we do everything we can to slow the growth of the virus. If the US had the same growth rate as Italy now at 465 cases per million, they would be dealing with 154,000 cases -- almost twice the current worldwide count.  Because we have so many people, its even more important we keep this virus as contained as possible.  




No comments:

Post a Comment